Technically, the mini gastric bypass sits between the sleeve and the classic gastric bypass. It has one bowel connection and may give the most weight loss, but has less long-term data. Which procedure fits depends on your situation.
Mini bypass, bypass and sleeve side by side
Three main types of procedure are performed in the Netherlands. According to DATO figures from 2019, 59% were Roux-en-Y gastric bypasses, 24% sleeves and 10% one anastomosis gastric bypasses. The table compares the main differences from the NVvH guideline.
| Mini gastric bypass (OAGB) | Gastric bypass (RYGB) | Gastric sleeve | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Bowel connections | 1 | 2 | 0 |
| Weight loss | very good, possibly the highest | good, long term best known | good, slightly more regain |
| Reflux | more than RYGB, less than sleeve | often improves | considerable risk (76% after 5 years) |
| Dumping | possible | more often (10-15%) | rare |
| Long-term data | limited | extensive | 5-10 years still limited |
| Share in NL (DATO 2019) | 10% | 59% | 24% |
Mini gastric bypass or gastric sleeve?
The sleeve is technically the simplest and feasible for almost everyone, including after previous abdominal surgery or with Crohn's disease. Its big drawback is reflux: according to the guideline it occurs in 76% after five years, and Barrett's oesophagus in 19%. In a randomised trial by Shivakumar (2018), excess weight loss at three years was 66.5% after a mini bypass and 61.2% after a sleeve; that difference was not clinically relevant.
Got a question about the OAGB?
Mini gastric bypass or classic gastric bypass?
The Roux-en-Y bypass has the longest track record, with extensive long-term data and good control of reflux. Dumping is more common (10 to 15%) and there is a risk of internal hernia. In a randomised trial by Lee (2005), excess weight loss after one year was 64.9% after a mini bypass and 58.7% after a classic bypass; after two years the difference was no longer significant. There were fewer early complications after the mini bypass.
From sleeve to mini gastric bypass: a revision
After a sleeve, a second operation is sometimes needed, mainly for persistent reflux or when weight returns. In the literature this reaches up to a quarter of patients. The sleeve is then usually converted to a Roux-en-Y bypass or a mini gastric bypass. That is possible because the narrow tube of a sleeve already resembles the stomach tube of a mini bypass; the surgeon mainly has to add the bowel connection.
Which of the two is better depends on the reason. A 2023 meta-analysis of six comparative studies found on average 5.7 percentage points more total weight loss after conversion to a mini bypass than after conversion to a Roux-en-Y bypass. Reflux resolved in 68.6% after the mini bypass and 80.6% after the Roux-en-Y; new reflux developed in 6.3% versus 0.5%. These differences were not statistically significant, but a Vienna study concluded that the Roux-en-Y is probably the best choice when reflux is the reason for revision. If weight regain is the main issue, the mini bypass is a realistic option.
How do you choose?
According to the guideline, you choose the procedure that brings your preference and your surgeon's closest together. Relevant factors are BMI, age, related conditions, reflux, previous abdominal surgery and medication. If you already have reflux, a sleeve is less obvious. If you have type 2 diabetes, a bypass variant may achieve more.
Also read: the one anastomosis gastric bypass explained and risks of the mini gastric bypass. By city: mini gastric bypass in Haarlem, mini gastric bypass in Hoofddorp, mini gastric bypass in Zaandam, mini gastric bypass in Amersfoort.
Frequently asked questions - mini gastric bypass compared with sleeve and bypass
Reflux and the mini gastric bypass: is it a good fit?
With existing reflux, surgeons often prefer a classic gastric bypass. You decide together with the surgeon, based on factors such as BMI, age, reflux and previous surgery.
Without insurance cover, what is the price of a mini gastric bypass?
Paying privately for the whole pathway in the Netherlands costs around €7,000-€11,000. Ask every time for a quotation including screening, the surgery itself and the aftercare.
How much time does the operation take?
A mini gastric bypass usually takes 60 to 90 minutes and is done by keyhole surgery. A hospital stay of 2 to 4 days usually follows.
Mini gastric bypass: can it be reversed?
Converting the connection is technically possible, such as to the classic gastric bypass. Of 8,676 patients in Italian research, 2.1% eventually required a second operation, and for 0.94% the reason was bile reflux.
How does it differ from a regular gastric bypass?
With a mini gastric bypass the surgeon makes a single bowel connection, compared with two for the classic Roux-en-Y. You get a longer, narrower stomach tube. According to the Dutch guideline the weight loss is very good; long-term figures are scarcer, however.
Must my GP refer me first?
Yes. Insurance only pays for the treatment if your GP or a specialist has referred you. In Utrecht, your GP can send you to whichever bariatric centre you choose.
How many kilos will come off?
Randomised studies report an average excess weight loss of 64.9% at one year (Lee 2005) and 66.5% at three years (Shivakumar 2018). The outcome can differ a lot from person to person.
Will I need vitamins after surgery?
Yes, for life. Because part of the small intestine is bypassed, you absorb fewer nutrients. Especially with a long limb there is a risk of deficiencies; regular blood tests are part of aftercare.
Sources
- Dutch Society for Surgery (NVvH) - Guideline Surgical treatment of obesity, module Surgical technique in adults (2020)
- Dutch guideline database - distribution of bariatric procedures in the Netherlands (DATO 2019)
- Carbajo et al. - OAGB: technique and long-term results in 1,200 patients (Obesity Surgery)
- OAGB versus RYGB as revision after sleeve: systematic review and meta-analysis (Langenbeck's Archives of Surgery, 2023)
- Sleeve converted to RYGB and OAGB: results from the Medical University of Vienna (Obesity Surgery)
- Five-year outcomes of OAGB as revision after sleeve for insufficient weight loss (Scientific Reports, 2022)
- StatPearls - One Anastomosis Gastric Bypass and Mini Gastric Bypass (NCBI Bookshelf)
- IFSO - One Anastomosis Gastric Bypass
Got a question about the OAGB?